Tags
- ancillary justice [12]
- art by meee [9]
- articles [27]
- ballet [13]
- being social [2]
- bodies amirite [3]
- book reviews [113]
- boston legal [8]
- brain and brain what is brain [9]
- btvs [10]
- byron [8]
- capitalism [2]
- chuck [1]
- comment on neglected favorites week [2]
- complaining [21]
- cons [37]
- dammit brain [2]
- dancing [5]
- david hallberg [8]
- deep existential questions [3]
- doctor who [4]
- dreams [50]
- ego waffles [2]
- energetic [1]
- equinox [7]
- fail [2]
- family [22]
- fanart [3]
- fandom has made me a feminist [1]
- fandom is a wonderful thing [22]
- fandom is scary [2]
- fandoms [1]
- fanfic meta [9]
- festivids [89]
- dear festividder [14]
- fic recs
- btvs/angel [2]
- doctor who [3]
- ds9 [2]
- game of thrones [1]
- house [32]
- hp [6]
- inception [17]
- mi-5/spooks [1]
- misc. [22]
- paul bettany-related [5]
- sga [41]
- star trek [5]
- vampire chronicles [3]
- vampire diaries [2]
- fic writing (or lack thereof) [72]
- fictional characters wear off on me [1]
- flaaaaan [11]
- fooooood [50]
- foreign languages [4]
- friends [66]
- game of thrones [11]
- giftedness [2]
- golem and the jinni [7]
- growing up [9]
- guess we're talking about american gods [2]
- guinea pigs [1]
- harold pinter [1]
- harry potter [24]
- hashtag first-world problems [6]
- health [16]
- holidays [48]
- hot hot photos [15]
- house
- how do i even tag this [8]
- i am crazy [6]
- i am not a sheep [1]
- i am not talking about american idol [2]
- i am not talking about inception [9]
- i am not talking about the avengers [1]
- i can't believe i'm posting this [12]
- i guess there should be a riddick tag [8]
- i hate people [1]
- i hate spoilers [1]
- i love fandom [12]
- i should have been a... [1]
- i'm a big dork [19]
- icons [2]
- inkheart [10]
- introversion [2]
- kink bingo [61]
- kink meta [15]
- lestat [7]
- life is good [19]
- literature [3]
- lj-versary [2]
- longmire [5]
- march of the living [13]
- mary suuuuue [16]
- medical writing [4]
- memes [32]
- memories [37]
- memoryfest [1]
- memoryfest ii [31]
- memoryfest iii [11]
- memoryfest iv [4]
- meta [15]
- movie reviews [161]
- music [36]
- must go back to school [2]
- my crush on zahn mcclarnon [15]
- my sister is way more cool than i am [12]
- my writing [109]
- news [5]
- nyc [4]
- obsession [12]
- oh god that was my brain [4]
- omfg [7]
- only at mit [5]
- overheard in the office [12]
- patronus [1]
- photos [37]
- podfic [3]
- podrec [1]
- poetry [24]
- politics [6]
- prompts [3]
- publishing [2]
- remember
- remix [18]
- resensitization [3]
- richard shindell [4]
- robots [7]
- rps [4]
- rsl [17]
- school [20]
- sci fi [4]
- sebastian [10]
- sestina!fic [7]
- sga [57]
- shameless pimping [2]
- shortfic challenge [1]
- slash [5]
- slash goes mainstream? [2]
- slayage [1]
- so much for no more lists [21]
- star trek [56]
- stories i am not writing honest [3]
- the end of the world [1]
- the unofficial paul bettany project [10]
- the vampire diaries [18]
- the wonders of procrastination [1]
- theater reviews [23]
- there is no tag for hair [2]
- thinky [11]
- thomas kretschmann [13]
- tim gunn is my future gay husband [7]
- tmi [11]
- too much to do [16]
- traveling [47]
- true blood [9]
- tumblr [1]
- turkeys [1]
- tv reviews [71]
- twilight [5]
- ugh men [1]
- vampire chronicles [27]
- vampires [40]
- vid [68]
- ancillary justice [8]
- starships [18]
- the greatest [12]
- vidding [145]
- vidrec [60]
- we don't do grammar here [10]
- weather [40]
- why'm i such a freak about money [4]
- wip [6]
- work [34]
- wtf [10]
- wwii [1]
- xy [1]
- yearly fanwork roundup [16]
- yes i like tentacles what of it [12]
- you know you've been in fandom too long [1]
Style Credit
- Style: Simplicity for Compartmentalize by
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: Apr. 28th, 2017 01:09 am (UTC)... I think the big thing is that I simply can't relate to the book's central conceit; even when I was a kid, I never had the feeling which apparently, I gather from the way other people have reacted to the book, that is evidently common, that children are losing something vital if they can't go back to their fantasy portal world as adults. I always found fantasy worlds fun to visit but not places I wanted to live in. I mean, not that anyone is wrong to feel this way; it's just that the whole concept of "children have to give up magic to become adults, and this is bad" was something that had never even occurred to me as a possible reading of that trope, until talking to other fantasy readers as an adult. I think it's mainly that to me, fantasy lands full of talking animals, where the rules were all different, were something that I found much more terrifying and uncertain than the real world, and as much as I loved reading fantasy, I also preferred the devil I knew to the even worse devil I didn't. So I'm obviously not the target audience for the book -- I'm probably more like the character mentioned in the review you linked to who can't go back to her fantasy world because she can't tolerate the high entropy of that world any more.
I do find the reviewer's comment in the review you linked to that 17-18 is too old for YA protagonist kind of puzzling, because I've read tons of YA with characters that age. Maybe they're thinking of middle grade?