House 4.2, "The Right Stuff"
Oct. 2nd, 2007 11:02 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
The Right Stuff: Does the roomful of team candidates have what it takes to work for one of the best diagnosticians in the world when he's not even sure what he's looking for? Does the patient have what it takes to fly space shuttles when she's driven by her lifelong dream but also suffering from a recurrent genetic disease that distorts her senses and happens to be triggered by stress (surely a constant companion for astronauts) not to mention that she'll need regular follow-up exams on the shiny new implants she didn't even want?
- I was very disappointed when House said he called NASA to inform them about -- Greta, was it? Especially after he made such a fuss about tattlers and went through so much trouble to keep her case off the record and has this long history of circumventing rules and undermining authority for the sake of the individual. To think that he kept up the pretense all episode just so he could solve his little puzzle and then ditch her because she got boring was horrible -- as horrible as the fact that it wouldn't have been the most awful thing he's done to a patient (or underling, or friend, or boss, or girlfriend, or himself) before. What a relief when he revealed that he hadn't actually done it! It confirmed that this season bears a closer resemblance to Season One than to Season Three, when House might well have sold his patient down the proverbial river (chucked her out the airlock?) when she ceased to interest him. We're back to the guy who'll risk his job and allow people to think badly of him for something he didn't do, all for the sake of his patient's health as well as her dreams; it reminded me of the risks he took for Carly in "Control" and the fall he took for the mother in "Socratic Method."
- Remind me how non-cancerous lung tumors led to synaesthesia?
- Happily, I won a bet with my coworker tonight. It had two parts: (a) the fellows really were back in the hospital and House wasn't hallucinating them, and (b) for at least a few episodes, they'll be on staff at PPTH but not in the capacity of House's team. Hooray! At least two out of three of our lovelies are back and helping out, and the class of 2011 has to keep fighting for a spot on House's Team, Round II, so we get the best of both possibilities.
- I can't picture Foreman running a Diagnostics department. His thinking is too rigid. Either he's going to screw up and kill someone and totally lose it, or he's going to call House for consults (after trying Cameron and Chase and Cuddy and maybe even Wilson first), or he's going to give it up and come crawling back to PPTH because he secretly likes it there, or he's not actually running a Diagnostics department at all.
- Chase was kinda smokin' when he stared at House from the observation room. Also, I quite enjoyed the transition from looking at woman/porpoise porn (for shock value rather than personal titillation, I'd guess) to seeing Chase in the hall.
- Wilson: flippy hair and babble and sarcasm and silly jokes and metaphor-following and psychoanalysis, yay. Well, not so much yay on that last, but it wasn't too bad tonight. He said what we were all thinking at several points, and it was good to have that out in the open. The only line I can remember right now went something like, "I love when repressed guilt unrepresses." Also: physics joke, double yay! Between Wilson's joke (and House getting it) and the Air Force/NASA pilot!patient, I was in my happy SGA crossover place for a few minutes.
- Also FTW was House having those clamps and all that specialized equipment so he could detail his Wilson-ravished guitar.
- But speaking of science (which we were a moment ago): What was with the Tesla references? First on the blackboard, and then didn't the patient say something about him when she was doubled over with the oxygen mask? Was there meant to be some thematic connection between someone having his work stolen, the group of candidates being eliminated, and the patient plot? Am I missing something very obvious? ETA: Yes: House called out the fellows-to-be on several occasions regarding who made decisions, who performed procedures, who let whom do what, who ratted out who else, who cheated, etc. I.e. fellows-to-be concerned with who gets credit for doing (what House thinks is) the right thing. Thanks,
elynittria!
- I don't know about you guys, but I'm liking the PPTH's Next Top Fellow competition. Had some trouble keeping track of who was who, but most of the really confusing ones ended up cut by the end anyway, which is how it should be. Everyone looked familiar, too, which didn't help (blue-eyed young man? Parker Posey-esque brunette? plastic surgeon?). I liked the aforementioned blue-eyed young man (Chase 2.0) and Parker Posey-esque brunette (pretty too!) as well as the older man whose dreams House also couldn't bring himself to crush. The Mormon channeled Foreman and personified a religious/ethical dilemma a little too much for him to feel like a person to me in his own right; we'll see if he comes back in subsequent weeks and distinguishes himself. The Russian (?) wasn't bad, either, nor was Kal-Penn-whom-everyone's-been-going-crazy-about-but-who-didn't-do-anything-special-really, and the curly blonde twins provided unexpected comic relief. I do have to say, though, that the "cutthroat pixie" (the show's embodiment of the majority of fandom's characterization of Cameron?) is one of my least favorite characters of the entire series, and I hope that either she goes away soon or there's some development that makes her interesting instead of totally annoying, even if "interesting" means "what she brings out in the characters around her."
- I really liked the patient and wish she'd had more screen time. She won me over in the teaser when, instead of falling unconscious or breaking down in the cockpit, she not only held it together despite being clearly spooked but also berated the guy running the simulator on two counts. Tables turned, expectant viewers! Her behavior there also neatly set up her episode-long (life-long, probably) desire to hide anything that would get her tossed out of the space program. I thought the lying would manifest as her hiding symptoms from House, but the direction they took it was much more entertaining. This time, "everybody lies" didn't (just) refer to the patient but to House (who lied to his students, to Cuddy, and to the patient), Wilson (who told House the fellows were in Arizona) and the fellows-in-training (who held out on Cuddy for the most part and eluded Security and double-crossed each other and performed one surgery to cover for another and had that quick but fun debate about whether they could believe anyone when House first brought in "Osama bin Laden" for her interrogation/history-taking), as well as Cuddy and the older fellow-in-training both lying by omission (Cuddy knowing House is performing tests he's not telling her about but letting him do it so she won't have to testify later [and perjure herself again], and of course the ?Columbia admissions department guy pretending he went to med school).
Hm. I'm sure there's more, but I didn't take any notes tonight so I can't remember. The end!
ETA: Now I have that stupid New Kids On The Block song stuck in my head. Thank you, episode title.
- I was very disappointed when House said he called NASA to inform them about -- Greta, was it? Especially after he made such a fuss about tattlers and went through so much trouble to keep her case off the record and has this long history of circumventing rules and undermining authority for the sake of the individual. To think that he kept up the pretense all episode just so he could solve his little puzzle and then ditch her because she got boring was horrible -- as horrible as the fact that it wouldn't have been the most awful thing he's done to a patient (or underling, or friend, or boss, or girlfriend, or himself) before. What a relief when he revealed that he hadn't actually done it! It confirmed that this season bears a closer resemblance to Season One than to Season Three, when House might well have sold his patient down the proverbial river (chucked her out the airlock?) when she ceased to interest him. We're back to the guy who'll risk his job and allow people to think badly of him for something he didn't do, all for the sake of his patient's health as well as her dreams; it reminded me of the risks he took for Carly in "Control" and the fall he took for the mother in "Socratic Method."
- Remind me how non-cancerous lung tumors led to synaesthesia?
- Happily, I won a bet with my coworker tonight. It had two parts: (a) the fellows really were back in the hospital and House wasn't hallucinating them, and (b) for at least a few episodes, they'll be on staff at PPTH but not in the capacity of House's team. Hooray! At least two out of three of our lovelies are back and helping out, and the class of 2011 has to keep fighting for a spot on House's Team, Round II, so we get the best of both possibilities.
- I can't picture Foreman running a Diagnostics department. His thinking is too rigid. Either he's going to screw up and kill someone and totally lose it, or he's going to call House for consults (after trying Cameron and Chase and Cuddy and maybe even Wilson first), or he's going to give it up and come crawling back to PPTH because he secretly likes it there, or he's not actually running a Diagnostics department at all.
- Chase was kinda smokin' when he stared at House from the observation room. Also, I quite enjoyed the transition from looking at woman/porpoise porn (for shock value rather than personal titillation, I'd guess) to seeing Chase in the hall.
- Wilson: flippy hair and babble and sarcasm and silly jokes and metaphor-following and psychoanalysis, yay. Well, not so much yay on that last, but it wasn't too bad tonight. He said what we were all thinking at several points, and it was good to have that out in the open. The only line I can remember right now went something like, "I love when repressed guilt unrepresses." Also: physics joke, double yay! Between Wilson's joke (and House getting it) and the Air Force/NASA pilot!patient, I was in my happy SGA crossover place for a few minutes.
- Also FTW was House having those clamps and all that specialized equipment so he could detail his Wilson-ravished guitar.
- But speaking of science (which we were a moment ago): What was with the Tesla references? First on the blackboard, and then didn't the patient say something about him when she was doubled over with the oxygen mask? Was there meant to be some thematic connection between someone having his work stolen, the group of candidates being eliminated, and the patient plot? Am I missing something very obvious? ETA: Yes: House called out the fellows-to-be on several occasions regarding who made decisions, who performed procedures, who let whom do what, who ratted out who else, who cheated, etc. I.e. fellows-to-be concerned with who gets credit for doing (what House thinks is) the right thing. Thanks,
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
- I don't know about you guys, but I'm liking the PPTH's Next Top Fellow competition. Had some trouble keeping track of who was who, but most of the really confusing ones ended up cut by the end anyway, which is how it should be. Everyone looked familiar, too, which didn't help (blue-eyed young man? Parker Posey-esque brunette? plastic surgeon?). I liked the aforementioned blue-eyed young man (Chase 2.0) and Parker Posey-esque brunette (pretty too!) as well as the older man whose dreams House also couldn't bring himself to crush. The Mormon channeled Foreman and personified a religious/ethical dilemma a little too much for him to feel like a person to me in his own right; we'll see if he comes back in subsequent weeks and distinguishes himself. The Russian (?) wasn't bad, either, nor was Kal-Penn-whom-everyone's-been-going-crazy-about-but-who-didn't-do-anything-special-really, and the curly blonde twins provided unexpected comic relief. I do have to say, though, that the "cutthroat pixie" (the show's embodiment of the majority of fandom's characterization of Cameron?) is one of my least favorite characters of the entire series, and I hope that either she goes away soon or there's some development that makes her interesting instead of totally annoying, even if "interesting" means "what she brings out in the characters around her."
- I really liked the patient and wish she'd had more screen time. She won me over in the teaser when, instead of falling unconscious or breaking down in the cockpit, she not only held it together despite being clearly spooked but also berated the guy running the simulator on two counts. Tables turned, expectant viewers! Her behavior there also neatly set up her episode-long (life-long, probably) desire to hide anything that would get her tossed out of the space program. I thought the lying would manifest as her hiding symptoms from House, but the direction they took it was much more entertaining. This time, "everybody lies" didn't (just) refer to the patient but to House (who lied to his students, to Cuddy, and to the patient), Wilson (who told House the fellows were in Arizona) and the fellows-in-training (who held out on Cuddy for the most part and eluded Security and double-crossed each other and performed one surgery to cover for another and had that quick but fun debate about whether they could believe anyone when House first brought in "Osama bin Laden" for her interrogation/history-taking), as well as Cuddy and the older fellow-in-training both lying by omission (Cuddy knowing House is performing tests he's not telling her about but letting him do it so she won't have to testify later [and perjure herself again], and of course the ?Columbia admissions department guy pretending he went to med school).
Hm. I'm sure there's more, but I didn't take any notes tonight so I can't remember. The end!
ETA: Now I have that stupid New Kids On The Block song stuck in my head. Thank you, episode title.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:09 am (UTC)Frankly, I wish the old fellows really were in Arizona and New York. It really doesn't make sense to have them all back at PPTH. They're history. Let's meet some new fellows!
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:14 am (UTC)We may get new fellows anyway. I'd be happy with a new team (so long as they're not Chase 2.0, Cameron 2.0 and Foreman 2.0) and the old team showing up for consults and/or to show the newbies how it's done.
I saw the Tesla scribbles (looked like "Tesca" the first few times, until it got rewritten) and actually asked about that up above because I'm not seeing the connection. Is House supposed to be Tesla? Is the patient?
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:19 am (UTC)I'd prefer to see the old team entirely gone (even though I'd miss Chase). It's more realistic, plus it would (maybe) allow Wilson to have a bit more screen time.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:24 am (UTC)my guess is that we'll have new fellows plus all the old gang in their new positions
That's what I've been hoping too, and I also don't know or want to know if it's where we're heading. Let me hope! Hee. As for romantic liaisons with Cameron, I am just not going there. If the show does, then the show does, and we'll see how they treat it. Otherwise, I'm not going to bother worrying. Also, I thought his main problems with dating her were the age difference, her need to fix people, and his difficulty letting people in, rather than the boss/employee imbalance? That certainly didn't stop her from propositioning/blackmailing him and didn't stop him from agreeing to a date back in the day.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:27 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:28 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:29 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:53 am (UTC)Sigh. Who knows?
I guess we can just hope that they'll keep throwing bones to all the ships without going all-out on one of them.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:54 am (UTC)Also much, much love for the physics joke. Kudos to the writers for reminding us that Wilson is smart -- that's one of the reasons House likes him, and I think that really got lost somewhere along the line.
*reposted because I'm an idiot. heh*
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:15 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:21 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:17 am (UTC)I actually had to sit there for a second though. "They didn't... did they? They totally just did!" Doris Egan for the win.
I do hope that House doesn't pick a team that's a carbon copy of his previous team.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 11:48 am (UTC)I hope we don't end up with the same team in different bodies, too. They hardly ever took C, C and F anywhere new as it was. To have the chance to start fresh with new people only to go where the show has gone over and over before is just sad.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:24 am (UTC)I still don't get why the ducklings are hanging around! They'll change specialties just to be "near" House? That is sooooo staged. *eyeroll*
I like PPTH'S Next Top Fellow too! It was fun guessing who would stay and who would go. At least the cutthroat pixie has a discernible personality and agenda, which makes her less generic. And some of the others stood out too, yay!
I didn't get the physics joke, but I loved that House did :D
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 11:53 am (UTC)At least the cutthroat pixie has a discernible personality and agenda, which makes her less generic.
I'm trying to decide if I'd take bland over "hate to hate" (as opp. "love to hate"). Will give her another week and see. It's always possible that House will take what Wilson said to heart and end up firing the people he really despises (e.g. her) and take on board people who can actually offer helpful, complementary perspectives.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:24 am (UTC)Yay, me too! I was also disappointed when he said he'd told NASA, and thought it seemed out of character of him, but then when he revealed that he'd been lying about it, well, yay. House is a jerk, but he does usually keep his patients' secrets when they ask him to. Or people's secrets in general.
And I too predicted the fellows were back at PPTH. I like seeing them working in other areas. I knew Wilson (and Cuddy) were fucking with him about that, lol.
And yeah, I liked the new potential underlings as well.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:46 pm (UTC)I like the thought that the old crew will stick around but in new, more independent positions that allow them to challenge House even more than before, and possibly serve as examples for the new kids.
And yes, I was definitely convinced that Wilson was yanking House's chain about Chase and Cameron the whole time, so even when he showed House the AZ area code, I was coming up with ways he could have faked it. Silly, gullible House; part of him was willing to believe that he was hallucinating them all out of residual guilt, no matter how much he denied it.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:28 am (UTC)Is he really from Columbia? I missed that. Foreman went to Columbia. *brainstorms*
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:30 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:32 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:34 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:31 am (UTC)House stopping Wilson dead in his tracks with his cane!
Oh yes. More threatening of Wilson with the cane, please.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 03:33 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:09 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:10 am (UTC)... and that's all I got.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 11:46 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 06:31 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 11:44 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 06:07 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 11:46 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:13 pm (UTC)Am I the only one who didn't feel like the Next Top Fellow competition was working? I loved last week's episode, but this one just felt... I dunno, kind of flat to me. I don't care about any of these new characters (with the possible exception of the older guy who didn't actually go to med school). The rest just strike me as blah.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 04:41 pm (UTC)Maybe it's a virtue of my having only become a fan of the show in the last 6 months or so [...] but I really want C,C, and F back.
I'd hesitate to say it's because you're newer to the show, because the fandom's divided in their opinions of the team regardless of how long they've been watching. I do suspect that if you'd seen the first two-and-some seasons, you'd be more aware of how the series tends to revisit the same plots over and over, how the characters go in circles and even seem to regress more than they progress, and in that sense, while they're fun to have around because they know House so well and they know their jobs (more or less) and it's comfortable because we've gotten to know them over three years, the possibility of having a new set of fellows is very welcome because it means we may go somewhere new. Unless they recast the new team in the mold of the old one, in which case, wah.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 06:05 pm (UTC)I agree that they do get into a bit of falling back on the usual suspects, but I also like how the characters have changed so slowly and subtly. Perhaps the reason I'm not enthused about House picking a new team is that, being king of denial that he is, I can't see him doing anything but picking carbon copies of his original fellows and ending up only filling their shoes with pale shadows of the originals. I guess I doubt that new fellows actually will go somewhere new at all and see it more as House's back-asswards way of avoiding change: he replaces Chase, Cameron, and Foreman with new fellows who are more like Chase, Cameron, and Foreman were three years ago. Then he doesn't have to deal with things like Chase being strikingly able to read him and actually starting to stand up to him.
I guess I could see going somewhere new if the new fellows ultimately fail and House has to admit to himself that the old team is worth getting back. That would mean that House himself actually has to change and develop as a character (though not, of course, into a kinder and gentler House). In a lot of ways, I think that he has been the most static of the bunch.
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 05:13 pm (UTC)I really like the Survivor:Fellowship thing, but that could just be because I love a few of the actors that are in it or that I know just a smidge of a spoiler about how it all progressess (but nothing about any outcome, I stopped reading there, I like House to surprise me, like how there was a lengthy and nice House/Cameron scene there for me at the end of the ep.)
Also, is it strange that every time House and Wilson interact as much as they did in this episode I catch myself thinking 'Wonder what she's going to think about this' :)
And to wrap it up, you tagged this entry under s3, not s4 :)
no subject
Date: Oct. 3rd, 2007 05:36 pm (UTC)And thanks for your sweet comment! I am honored to be on your mind when you watch the show and to entertain with these recaps. It's always a pleasure when someone new pokes their head up to say that they're reading and enjoying.
I really like the Survivor:Fellowship thing, but that could just be because I love a few of the actors that are in it or that I know just a smidge of a spoiler about how it all progressess
I don't know where they're going, but I'm enjoying the ride so far. Even though the show has disappointed and confused me in the past, I like to keep an open mind. Staying optimistic makes episode-watching much more enjoyable and less stressful, don't you think? Even if sometimes it feels naive to do so.
no subject
Date: Oct. 4th, 2007 08:26 pm (UTC)I have to say, I'm liking season four so far. I mean, House has its flaws, but as long as nothing *horrible* happens *cough*Tritter*cough* I can run with it. Or giggle at its foolishness (see One Day, One Room).
I haven't commented on here in far too long, but I thought You'd like to know that your posts make my f-list a prettier place.
And, I have to say, I'm liking the slightly more chilled version of Wilson.
no subject
Date: Oct. 6th, 2007 10:32 pm (UTC)I'm liking season four so far.
Yes yes. Two for two -- although, speaking of "One Day, One Room," I am very wary of next week's.
Definitely enjoying Wilson so far, too. A major improvement over lecturing!Wilson and lying-for-your-own-good-with-no-sense-of-humor!Wilson and pitiful-victim!Wilson, etc. Keeping my fingers crossed that he (a) keeps showing up, and (b) keeps getting to be funny and/or effective.
no subject
Date: Oct. 7th, 2007 04:23 pm (UTC)As long as HL gets to have awesome lines, and Wilson gets to be funny and interesting, I'll be happy. The new fellows/old fellows thing - well, either option could go either way, so I don't want to hedge my bets, or decide I don't like what's happening just because it isn't what I thought should happen. I mean, I think House and Wilson should mess around in a cleaning closet and get found by Cuddy, but that doesn't mean I cry every time it doesn't.
(Just that I go off and write it myself, heh).
no subject
Date: Oct. 10th, 2007 12:37 am (UTC)